Play It Again Sports



We buy, sell & trade
Sports Gear Sports Gear
Your neighborhood Play It Again Sports store buys and sells quality new and used sports and fitness equipment.

(click on picture for a Play It Again commerical)

Congratulations to our sales associate Cameron Gilreath!  Cameron graduated from Harrison High School in May and has signed to play Division 1 soccer at the University of Evansville!

Cameron has been playing soccer his whole life.  He has been working for us for a couple months now.  Cameron will continue to work with us during the off season with the Aces.  Way to go Cameron!! 


                                                                                                                            (click on logo to read more about Cameron)




At Play It Again Sports we specialize in NEW and USED fitness, hockey, baseball, lacrosse, football, softball, golf, disc golf, water sports, and soccer. We also carry a full line of Spirit Wear for the high schools in the greater Evansville area:  hoodies, t-shirts, cinch bags, tote bags, and stadium chairs.  

As your kids grow, we want to make it possible for them to have the gear they need to play the game of their choice at an affordable price.  We will make sure they have the right equipment for their sport and that it performs for them.


We are located at 5626 E. Virginia Street in Evansville, IN.  Metro Sports Center is directly behind us...just look for our big white garage door as you walk out their front door. Our store is situated in Metro Shoppes, sharing the center with Fired Up, Nagasaki Inn, and located between Kidz Hair Club & Wild Birds Unlimited. Our location offers easy access and plenty of close parking.

Join our mailing list and you will receive advance notice of special events, markdowns, and coupons for Play It Again Sports Evansville!

We can be reached at 812-479-3289 (47W-EBUY) for any questions or you can email us at:




Our Location

5626 E. Virginia Street
Evansville, IN 47715

Hours of Operation

Sunday 12:00 PM-5:00 PM
Monday 10:00 AM-8:00 PM
Tuesday 10:00 AM-8:00 PM
Wednesday 10:00 AM-8:00 PM
Thursday 10:00 AM-8:00 PM
Friday 10:00 AM-8:00 PM
Saturday 10:00 AM-6:00 PM
Gold Standard = This location has received the Gold Standard Seal. They have been recognized for achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations and Customer Service.

Recent Sports News

Exploring the benefits of caffeine

Posted On April, 1, 2014

Being successful at playing a sport, whether it is baseball, football or soccer, takes a great deal of focus and concentration.

Dramatically improve your vertical leap

Posted On March, 27, 2014

Every athlete playing a major sport like basketball, baseball or football, has spent time, money and energy adding inches to their vertical leap. Individuals who can jump higher in these sports simply have a better chance of outperforming their competitors in a game situation. Players with a great vertical leap can grab more rebounds, pull down off-target passes and make great catches on deep fly balls. By following these vertical leap exercises and applying proper jumping techniques, you can also increase the height of your jump and therefore improve your performance during competition.

Reduce your recovery time after workouts with these tips

Posted On March, 25, 2014

Every sport, from football to baseball and hockey, is physically demanding on the human body. In order to protect yourself from injury and perform at peak levels, you have to spend a lot of time at the gym building strength and endurance. However, one of the biggest setbacks athletes experience after hard exercise is muscle soreness. This might prevent you from staying with a workout routine and limit your performance on the field. Try out a few of these recovery tips designed to get you in the gym consistently:

Read more sports news »

Now Paying Top $$$ For Your Used Gear

Shoot us an email or give us a call!!